LA TIMES 8-27-02

The only one ignoring the central tenet of libertarian philosophy is Vincent. Libertarians do not believe in initiating the use of force as a means of achieving political or social goals.

If people do not like smoking in bars and restaurants, they are free to stay away from bars and restaurants where it is allowed, and they are free to establish bars and restaurants where it is prohibited. Similarly, people who like to smoke in bars and restaurants should be free to do so if they please.

The problems start when one side seeks to use the power of government to impose its position on the other. Imagine how indignant Vincent would be about the assault on her rights if New York City passed a law requiring all bars and restaurants to allow smoking.

Robert A. Philipson

Santa Monica